- "Defeat the tornado".
- "You calmed the fury of the storm".
This achievement is awarded when the player defeats the tornado over Cauldron Lake. It is a story-related achievement that takes place right before Alan seemingly enters the lake for the last time. Once the player makes their way to the platform right in front of the tornado, they will find a flare gun, as well as unlimited flare ammo. The tornado need only be shot with 4 or 5 flares on normal difficulty, before it "dies". Once the tornado dissolves, the achievement is awarded.